Useful physics equations for military system analysis

Speculation on military systems often turns into an exchange of uninformed guesstimates, obtained by eyeballing measurements. While in most cases it is the best that can be done without access to classified information, physical laws still apply to those systems. A handful of physics formula help constrain their performance, so I have gathered a few here (mostly for my future use). They deal with radar and optical sensors, ballistics and finally aerodynamics.

 

Radar

Radar horizon

img714.gif

2018-05-26 13_59_16-Document1 - Microsoft Word

R is the radar horizon range in kilometers, h is the antenna height in meter, and a is the target altitude in meter. It limits the detection range of radars (and optical sensors too) no matter their power.

 

Radar equation

2018-05-26 21_39_17-radar equation - Recherche Google

with R the maximum range a target of radar cross-section σ can be detected by a radar with minimal detectable power Pe. Ps is the emitted power, G the antenna’s gain,  λ is the wavelength of the radar. A more complete form of the equation gives the radar’s signal to noise ratio (SNR) for the same target:

2018-05-26 21_41_31-Correct Radar Range Equation for SNR at Detection - Signal Processing Stack Exch

With Pn being the power of the electronic noise, Pt the emitted power and Ps the power of the target’s return, Gt and Gr the gains on transmission and reception (assumed to be the same in the first formula), k the Boltzmann constant, To the temperature of the receiver or of the background the radar is looking at, B the bandwidth of the radar, Fn the noise figure of the receiver and L the emission+reception losses between the antenna and the electronics.

 

Antenna gain

2018-05-26 21_52_24-Antenna aperture - Wikipedia.png

G is the gain of an antenna of effective area Aeff (or of physical area Aphys and efficiency Ea) at wavelength λ. It is limited by the diffraction of radio waves.

 

Radar cross section of a flat surface

2018-05-28 23_34_14-Document1 - Microsoft Word

Radar cross section σ of a rectangular reflective plate of dimensions Lx and Ly, seen at the angle (θx,θy) and at wavelength λ. A larger surface has a larger RCS when viewed head-on but the energy is spread over a narrower angle. sinc is the cardinal sine function.

Radar range resolution

2019-10-27 13_43_32-Document1 - Microsoft Word

The range resolution ΔR is the resolution of a radar in the direction of the line of sight towards a target. In other words, it is the resolution in distance, or along the radar beam. It depends on c, the speed of light, and β, the bandwidth of the radar.

Radar cross-range resolution

2019-10-27 13_49_43-Document1 - Microsoft Word

The cross-range resolution ΔX is the resolution perpendicular to the radar beam. It is much worse than the range resolution and depends on the wavelength λ, the range R of the target and the diameter D of the antenna.

Radar Doppler resolution

2019-10-27 21_03_51-Document1 - Microsoft Word

Using the Doppler effect, a radar can measure the speed of targets towards or away from it (ie in the radial or range direction). The speed resolution ΔV depends on the wavelength λ and 𝜏,  the time during which the target is observed.

Radar range-Doppler resolution

2019-06-23 15_38_16-21_1_3_Czerwinski.pdf - Adobe Reader

A radar can build a precise picture of objects by combining its good range and Doppler resolution. This is called range-Doppler imaging or Inverse Synthetic Aperture Radar (ISAR). The resolutions are given in the figure above.

 

Optics

Resolution of a telescope

2018-05-26 14_03_02-Document1 - Microsoft Word.png

D is the distance to the target, a is the aperture (diameter/width) of the sensor, λ is the wavelength of the sensor. This is the maximum resolution, limited by the diffraction of electromagnetic waves.

 

Minimum size of a focused beam

2018-05-26 21_32_19-Document1 - Microsoft Word

2018-05-26-21_32_19-document1-microsoft-word1-e1527363258907.png is the full width of the spot beam of a laser of wavelength λ focusing at a distance f using a mirror of diameter d. The spot can be much smaller than the mirror, so the laser can concentrate its energy and destroy materials much tougher than the mirror’s material.

 

Ballistics

Speed of a rocket after burnout (Tsiolkovski’s equation)

2018-05-26 13_54_06-Tsiolkovsky rocket equation - Wikipedia.png

Δ is the speed difference between before ignition and at burnout, v_eis the ejection speed of the rocket’s gasses (usually around 2000m/s for solid rockets, and usually reported as the specific impulse), m_{i}is the initial mass of the rocket (fuel + the rest) before ignition, and m_f the final mass after burnout

 

Range of a rocket

2018-05-26 13_54_48-Portée (balistique) — Wikipédia

d is the distance crossed by a rocket in parabolic flight, ignoring aerodynamic forces. v is the initial speed of the rocket, g is the acceleration of gravity and θ the firing angle (0 for horizontal firing). It is only valid for ranges far smaller than the perimeter of the Earth.

 

Time of flight

2018-05-26 13_54_40-Portée (balistique) — Wikipédia

t is the duration the rocket spend in flight, the rest is the same as above.

 

Max range

2018-05-26 13_54_48-Portée (balistique) — Wikipédia

This is the maximum range of a rocket, obtained when θ = 45°, and is valid for ranges far smaller than the perimeter of the Earth. For long ranges, the relationship is this:

2018-11-01 20_20_26-Window

and the injection angle needed to achieve it is given by

2018-11-01 20_20_03-Window.png

Max altitude at max range

2018-05-26 14_06_51-Document1 - Microsoft Word

For the maximum range trajectory, the rocket reaches a maximum altitude of h

 

Max altitude with a purely vertical trajectory

2018-05-26 14_10_40-Parabole de sûreté — Wikipédia

Vo is the initial speed, and h is the maximum altitude reached when firing with θ = 90°

 

Reentry

During reentry, a reentry vehicle experiences its maximum deceleration at altitude

2020-05-20 11_22_50-Document1 - Microsoft Word

with β the atmosphere scale height, ρ0 the atmospheric density at sea level,  Cd the coefficient of drag of the vehicle, A it frontal area, m its mass and θ the reentry angle.

The speed is given by

2020-05-20 11_27_35-Document1 - Microsoft Word

with Δy=y-y0 and V0 the speed before rentry

Applied to a 150kg conical IBCM warhead with a coefficient of drag of 0.3 and a diameter of 30cm, on a 22° reentry trajectory, this give a maximum deceleration altitude of 10km, at which point the warhead goes at 5km/s. At sea level, the speed is 2km/s.

The ultimate tool for rocket trajectory and design simulation is ZOOM. It can optimize both at the same time, giving a good estimate of what professional rocket designers would end up with given a required range and payload, and with a given level of technology.

Aerodynamics

Range of a jet aircraft (Breguet’s range equation)

img1614

V is the speed of the aircraft, L/D is lift/drag coefficient, Isp the specific impulse of its engines, Wi the mass at take-off and Wf the mass at landing

Gliders

Missiles that move through the atmosphere are gliders, as they are in general unpowered once the booster shuts off.

Gliding range

Max range R of a glider before it hits the ground:

V0 is the initial speed (if it a air-launched missile, the initial speed depends on the speed of the launching aircraft), g the acceleration of gravity, L/D the lift-to-drag ratio, H the initial altitude.

Intercept range while gliding

Max range of an intercept against a target of speed Rt and distance R at the moment of the shot:

Velocity loss of a glider in a turn:

Δθ is the turn angle, Δv the speed lost to drag in the turn

3 thoughts on “Useful physics equations for military system analysis

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s